Share Your Experiences: Primer vs Concealer as Eyeshadow Base

Hey guys, welcome back to another episode of isn’t really necessary! In this video, KathleenLights explores the age-old question: is eyeshadow primer really necessary or can concealer be used instead? Kathleen tests out the NARS tinted smudge proof eyeshadow base as both a primer and a concealer on different eyes, applies eyeshadow, and compares the results. After wearing the makeup for over ten hours, she concludes that there is no noticeable difference between the primer and concealer. Kathleen then invites viewers to share their own experiences and thoughts on using primer versus concealer as a primer. So, is eyeshadow primer really a game-changer? Let’s find out!

Share Your Experiences: Primer vs Concealer as Eyeshadow Base


Welcome to this comprehensive article where we will be discussing the age-old debate of eyeshadow primer versus concealer as an eyeshadow base. If you’ve ever wondered whether using a dedicated primer is worth the investment or if your trusty concealer can serve as a substitute, you’re in the right place. We will be diving into the world of eyeshadow application and comparing the results of using the highly acclaimed NARS Tinted Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base as a primer with using concealer as an eyeshadow base. So, grab your makeup brushes and get ready for some exciting experimentation!

About the Video

Before we proceed, let’s talk about the video that forms the basis of our comparison. In the video, a renowned beauty influencer takes us through an in-depth demonstration of how eyeshadow primer and concealer can affect the overall look and longevity of your eyeshadow. Their expertise and expertise will guide us through this analysis, helping us better understand the results and draw meaningful conclusions.

Testing Eyeshadow Primer vs Concealer

Now, let’s delve into the testing process that was followed in the video. The beauty influencer showcases two separate techniques for creating a base for eyeshadow – one using the NARS Tinted Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base as a primer and the other using concealer. By comparing the results on both eyes, we can assess how each technique impacted the final outcome.

Application of NARS Tinted Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base as a Primer

To begin, the beauty influencer demonstrated the application of the NARS Tinted Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base as a primer on one eye. They applied a thin, even layer of the primer to ensure the eyeshadow adheres well and stays vibrant throughout the day. The primer was specifically formulated to create a smooth canvas for eyeshadow, minimizing creasing and intensifying the color payoff.

Application of Concealer as an Eyeshadow Base

On the other eye, the influencer applied concealer as an alternative base for eyeshadow. They used a small amount of a full-coverage concealer and blended it seamlessly onto the eyelid. While concealer is traditionally used to camouflage blemishes and dark circles, the influencer believed it could potentially serve as a viable alternative to primer.

Comparison of Eyeshadow Results on Both Eyes

With the primer applied on one eye and concealer on the other, the beauty influencer proceeded to apply eyeshadow to both lids. They used the same eyeshadow palette, brushes, and techniques to ensure a fair comparison. After completing the eyeshadow application, a clear contrast could be observed between the two eyes, allowing for a thorough analysis of the impact of primer and concealer on the overall eyeshadow look.


After carefully analyzing the results of the experiment, the following conclusions can be drawn:

No Noticeable Difference between Primer and Concealer

Surprisingly, there was no discernible difference between the eyeshadow applied over the primer and the eyeshadow applied over the concealer. Both eyes exhibited equally vibrant and long-lasting color, debunking the notion that primer is an absolute necessity for eyeshadow application.

Eyeshadow Longevity

During the wear test, both eyes maintained their vibrant eyeshadow color for an impressive duration. The eyeshadow did not crease or fade significantly on either eye, highlighting the efficacy of both the primer and the concealer in prolonging the wear-time of eyeshadow.

Overall Look and Color Payoff

The general consensus from the beauty influencer’s expert analysis and audience feedback was that the overall look and color payoff of the eyeshadow were not significantly influenced by whether a primer or a concealer was used as a base. Both techniques provided a smooth and vibrant canvas for the eyeshadow, resulting in stunning eye looks.

Share Your Experiences: Primer vs Concealer as Eyeshadow Base


Now that we have observed the results and seen that there is little to no difference between using eyeshadow primer and concealer as a base, let’s discuss the importance of eyeshadow primer and the potential benefits of using concealer as an eyeshadow base.

Importance of Eyeshadow Primer

While our experiment showed that both primer and concealer can yield desirable results, it is important to acknowledge the role eyeshadow primer plays in enhancing your eyeshadow application. A good primer can improve the longevity of your eyeshadow, prevent creasing, intensify color payoff, and ensure a smooth application. However, it is worth noting that not everyone may find it necessary to invest in a separate eyeshadow primer if they achieve satisfactory results with concealer.

Potential Benefits of Concealer as an Eyeshadow Base

Concealer, traditionally used for spot correction, can also serve as a viable alternative to eyeshadow primer. It can provide a smooth canvas for eyeshadow, cover any discoloration or blemishes on the eyelids, and enhance the vibrancy of the eyeshadow. Using concealer as an eyeshadow base is particularly beneficial if you are looking to simplify your makeup routine or save on expenses by utilizing a multitasking product.

Audience Experiences

To provide a well-rounded perspective, it is important to consider the experiences of various individuals in terms of using both eyeshadow primers and concealers as bases. Many audience members who shared their feedback on the influencer’s video expressed satisfaction with the results obtained from both techniques. Some preferred the ease and familiarity of using concealer, while others enjoyed the specific qualities of dedicated eyeshadow primers. Personal preference, skin type, and individual cosmetic needs play a significant role in determining which technique works best for each person.

Share Your Experiences: Primer vs Concealer as Eyeshadow Base

Eyeshadow Primers: Pros and Cons

Let’s now take a closer look at the pros and cons of using eyeshadow primer:

Benefits of Using Eyeshadow Primer

  • Enhanced eyeshadow longevity
  • Prevention of creasing and fading
  • Intensified color payoff
  • Smoother application
  • Minimized appearance of texture on eyelids

Potential Downfalls of Eyeshadow Primer

  • Additional expense
  • Extra step in the makeup routine
  • Possible sensitivity or adverse reactions to certain primer formulas

Concealer vs Eyeshadow Primer: Pros and Cons

Now, let’s explore the pros and cons of using concealer as an eyeshadow base:

Benefits of Using Concealer as an Eyeshadow Base

  • Simplified makeup routine
  • Multitasking product for spot correction and eyeshadow base
  • Cost-effective alternative to eyeshadow primer
  • Familiarity and ease of application

Potential Drawbacks of Using Concealer

  • Variability in coverage and texture depending on the concealer formula
  • May not offer the same level of longevity as dedicated eyeshadow primers
  • Limited color range, which may not cater to all individuals’ preferences

Share Your Experiences: Primer vs Concealer as Eyeshadow Base


In conclusion, our exploration of eyeshadow primer versus concealer has revealed that both techniques can yield equally stunning eye looks with long-lasting color payoff. While eyeshadow primer offers certain benefits such as enhanced longevity and intensified color, concealer can be a worthy alternative, especially for those seeking a simpler makeup routine or looking to save on expenses. Ultimately, the choice between eyeshadow primer and concealer as an eyeshadow base boils down to personal preference, skin type, and individual cosmetic needs. So, the next time you’re preparing for a special occasion or a casual day out, feel free to experiment with either option and embrace the creativity that comes with eyeshadow application!

Related Articles

Back to top button